Nia spent months in a secret relationship with Carter, loving him in private while he chased other girls publicly and kept her hidden like a shameful secret. When she catches him in bed with another woman and he calls her pathetic, she forgives him but Nia's heartbreak turns to anger after overhearing Carter tell his friends she was never good enough to stand beside him. Knox, Carter's older brother and campus bad boy, offers Nia a deal, if she tutored him to save his failing grades and hockey scholarship, he'll make her seem out of Carter's league for revenge. What starts as mutual manipulation becomes complicated when Knox's reputation begins changing and real feelings develop between them. But when Nia discovers Knox was also using her to clean up his image for sponsorships, she must decide if his love is genuine or if she's being played by another brother.